Good Starch vs Bad Starch

Nutrition

carbohydrates and starchy foods

In this post...

All Articles

We all know that excessive amounts of biscuits, pastries and soft drinks can skyrocket blood sugar levels and lead to adverse effects on health. But did you know that the same could be true for certain types of starch as well? Here we’ll look at starches from different carbohydrate sources, how they respond inside your body and how they may be impacting your performance.

Amylopectin Starch vs Amylose Starch

Starch is a mixture of two polysaccharides: amylopectin and amylose.

Amylopectin

Amylopectin is a branched chain of glucose molecules (visualise this as multiple branches on a tree). It has a greater surface area, making it easily digestible than amylose. While this may sound like a good thing, it actually means that eating foods rich in this Amylopectin carb can spike blood sugar and insulin levels, causing an increase in triglycerides (fat) and cholesterol levels within the body.

amylose vs amylopectin

Amylose

Amylose is a linear chain of glucose molecules (visualise this like a single tree trunk). This kind of starch takes longer to digest due to its low surface area. Resulting in less of a spike in blood sugar and insulin. Amylose tend to have higher levels of resistant starch, a type of starch that isn’t completely broken down or absorbed by the body. Resistant starch has been shown to reduce fat storage, increase satiety, lower cholesterol levels and blood sugar, and improve insulin sensitivity.

Although starches contain both of these amylopectin and amylose, a high amount of amylopectin can also increase the glycemic index of foods, which is a measure of how much blood sugar levels increase after consumption.

Negative Effects of Amylopectin

Spikes Blood Sugar and Insulin

Foods with a higher amount of amylopectin have a higher glycemic index, which means they can cause a quick increase in blood sugar and insulin levels.

Insulin is the hormone that is responsible for the transportation of sugar from the blood to the tissues where it can be utilised. Having high levels of insulin over a long period of time, can decrease the effectiveness of insulin, leading to insulin resistance and high blood sugar.

Increased Belly Fat

Eating foods with a high ratio of amylopectin can lead to an increase in visceral fat, most visibly seen around your waistline. Amylopectin and other high glycemic foods can increase insulin, which plays a major role in metabolism and fat storage. 

Insulin stops triglycerides from breaking down and going into fat cells, so therefore it causes these triglycerides to float around body impacting our cholesterol and ultimately visceral body fat.

man with high belly fat

Raises Cholesterol Levels

Research shows that eating a diet high in amylopectin can negatively impact good HDL blood cholesterol levels.

Starchy Foods Choices

Although all starches contain some amylopectin, certain types may have a higher ratio of amylopectin than others. Simple carbs that have a high glycemic index are likely to be higher in amylopectin while foods with a lower glycemic index are likely higher in amylose.

High-amylopectin foods include:

  • Short-grain rice
  • White bread
  • Bagels
  • White potatoes
  • Cookies
  • Crackers
  • Pretzels
  • Instant oatmeal
  • Puffed rice
  • Cornflakes
  • Rice cakes

High-amylose foods include:

  • Long-grain rice
  • Oats
  • Quinoa
  • Sweet potatoes
  • Bananas
  • Whole wheat
  • Barley
  • Rye
  • Beans
  • Legumes

Study

There was a study published in the Journal of Nutrition. They tested subjects for 16 weeks eating a high amylopectin diet. After 16 weeks, test subjects ended up having a 50% increase in insulin. They also ended up having a 50% increase in insulin resistance too, a key marker for onset of diabetes.

About the Author

Performance coach Jay Jadva is the creator of The J5 Method and multiple health programs. Jay hosts The Way of The Trainer podcast and founded A.C.T.S, Association of Certified Transformation Specialists, mentoring the next generation of fitness coaches in the creative arts and media industry.

Jay in a gym with weight training equipment
About Jay

Free mini-courses

I want to burn fat

Struggling with stubborn fat? Learn why 95% of diets fail and how traditional weight loss methods often sabotage your results. This eye-opening series debunks common myths and reveals industry secrets helping you sculpt your dream physique.

Fat Loss Mastery (3 Videos)

An athletic woman ready to begin a fat loss workout

I want to build muscle

Lacking muscle and frustrated by confusing advice? Learn to train smarter, not harder, and amplify your muscle building potential. This exclusive series unveils the true reasons behind your slow progress. You’ll master the art of lifting technique, tailor your nutrition and optimise recovery for effective muscle growth.

Muscle Building Coaching (3 Videos)

weight lifter struggling to build muscle

I want to master sleep

Exhausted by endless nights of poor sleep? This insightful training exposes the surprising factors behind poor sleep and their impact on your wellbeing. Learn how to optimise your sleep routine and harness your body’s natural sleep cycles for deep, restorative rest. You’ll master science-backed strategies to transform your mornings from sluggish to supercharged.

Sleep & Thrive (3 Videos)

woman struggling to sleep lying awake in bed